Brandon

What a horrible day for news!
- There have been several, enormous, co-ordinated bombing and mortar attacks in Baghdad. It looks like terrorist groups are reorganising themselves there now and it seems that they believe killing on an enormous, indiscriminate scale is the only way for them to be heard.
- Violence is gaining pace in Kabul ahead of the elections in Afghanistan tomorrow. Again, offered the chance to use the democratic voice that the West believes is the answer to life’s ills, some people prefer the opportunity to mutilate men, women and children on a large, indiscriminate level.
- An independent review has stated that the murder of Brandon Muir, a 23-month-old boy in Dundee, couldn’t have been predicted. Brandon was left alone with his mum’s boyfriend, Robert Cunningham, who hit him so hard that four of his ribs were broken and his intestines burst. Brandon’s mum was involved in heroine misuse and prostitution – something that’s being used by the media to redirect the blame from her son’s murderer back onto her.
Sometimes, when I drive home from work and hear all this stuff, things just seem so hopeless. I must admit that the child abuse stories have a particularly strong effect on me.
Recently, when the Baby P case was in the media and the sentencing of his murderers was carried out, the story of his murderer raping a two year old girl was also reported. Apparently, the young rape victim was able to give evidence for the court to convict the man. I was really moved by the knowledge that this little girl was strong enough to do such a thing – this really is an incredible feat of bravery, something that most adults who have been through similar things aren’t capable of.
What struck me today, as the news reporter tried to find somewhere to place blame for Brandon’s death (social workers? other professionals? his mother?) was that, other than the obvious need to punish and rehabilitate his murderer, no specific group can be labelled with blame. Sure, maybe his mum should have chosen better boyfriends or not left her boy alone in the care of a dangerous man; maybe social workers should be more ready to remove children from the care of people who are dependent on intravenous drugs; maybe the government should offer the social care sector more support to enable them to tackle to huge amount of cases coming their way; maybe the media should stop demonising social workers, so there would be more people willing to take the strain and enter the profession. But I think the reason for Brandon’s death, for the murder and abuse of kids, is far bigger than all these ideas.
Because why would an adult be violent towards a child? Usually because the adult is feeling angry for some reason and responds with violence, or perhaps they have sadistic feelings and direct them at the child. Why would an adult treat a child sexually? It’s just a way for the adult to deal with their own feelings and gain some pleasure. Why would a person decided to blow themselves up and take a few others with them, injuring several others? Because they feel that people won’t listen otherwise and this might gain them some kudos.
It’s all just about the self. It’s all about me. It’s what I feel. It’s how I’ve decided to deal with this emotion. Sure, the child was in immense pain for the final couple of days of his prematurely ended life, but at least his killer felt that rush of adrenaline that made him feel better for a second or two. OK, so mothers and fathers will lose their children and children will lose their parents, but at least the bomber made their point and felt special as they exploded themselves. The politician on the radio this morning appeared to be slightly upset by the interviewer’s rudeness, but the interviewer had the satisfaction of knowing he had made most of his listeners smile, so it was worth it. So I caused pain, but I felt good about it, which makes it alright.
The fact that child abuse happens has very little to do with social workers. It has everything to do with the fact that, for some reason, we are convinced that our desires are there to be indulged. As soon as our desires, our feelings or what we perceive as our needs gain importance, the rest of humanity loses some significance.
I know it’s a ridiculously simple idea. It’s laughable really. And it feels like a total cliché to bring this up, but isn’t a good idea to live in the knowledge that I am not the centre of the universe. What I do will effect others and it is worth bearing that in mind. Whenever I choose to buy coffee that tastes like liquid gold, but was produced unfairly, I place my desires above the humanity of others. Whenever a child is mistreated, their humanity is being disregarded for the benefit of their abuser.
This little golden rule sums it up far more succinctly than I ever will:
Do to others whatever you would like them to do to you.
It’s really hard and, although I try to do it everyday, I think I fail more than I succeed. But it’s well worth the effort.
